By Manuella Irwin
Updated: Sep 5, 2026
6 min read
Reviewed by Martin Pаnауоtоv
Editor
Martin is founder of MoveAdvisor, formerly MyMovingReviews.com.
917 movers in East Setauket
"The man that assembled my bed had no idea how to handle a screwdriver. He put about a dozen or so noticeable Nick's on the top of my bed frame. Some are deep enough to need wood filler. I also noticed that he only put approximately half the screws..."
"Central Moving Systems is affiliated with United Van Lines. I scheduled an estimate and they didn't confirm so I called to confirm and was told that they didn't have an appointment for me. Then the guy showed up at my door. He left information for..."
"Mike O'Connor is an excellent salesman. Very good at his job, very friendly and so is his staff UNTIL you have a problem. With that said, he will tell you "anything" you want to hear to get your business. I'm currently going into arbitration with ..."
"Do Not under any circumstances use this mover. They deliberately created chaos in my home.Then they went in for the kill when they put my boxes in my apartment. They stole the picture I had personally wrapped myself. I told them it was my pride an..."
"The men you did the actual moving were great! The woman who answers the phone is HORRIBLE. It says Moving and STORAGE. They will NOT give me access to my own things in storage! I have to move the entire crate. The men who moved told me all I had t..."
"BEWARE OF BEACON! If I could give them zero stars I would. Car arrived 7 days late. Driver was MIA when dispatcher was trying to him. I was not told that he was picking up cars along the way. And the worst part was my car was damaged and Beacon an..."
What to know when moving to East Setauket, NY
TL;DR: East Setauket at a Glance
- The Vibe:
- A highly educated ZIP where 62.9% hold a bachelor's degree and only 15.2% of residents rent.
- The Major Draw:
- Median household income is $174,931, making it one of the wealthier areas in New York.
- The Reality Check:
- Median gross rent is $2,386, which may be high for some budgets.
- Commute:
- Only 3.5% of residents use public transit.
- Top Tip:
- Prepare for a competitive housing market with median home values at $653,100.
The 'Vibe' Check: Who Thrives Here?
East Setauket attracts a highly educated crowd, with 62.9% of residents holding a bachelor's degree or higher. The community reflects affluence, with a median household income of $174,931. While homeownership is common, with 84.8% of residents owning their homes, the significant rental market comes with a median gross rent of $2,386, making it a higher-cost area for renters. With only 3.5% of residents using public transit, expect a car-dependent lifestyle.
Probably not your spot if you are seeking affordable rental options or a robust public transit system.
Your Money: Housing & Cost Snapshot
- Median gross rent is $2,386, indicating a higher cost of living.
- Median owner-occupied home value is $653,100, suggesting significant investment for homeowners.
- 62.9% of residents have a bachelor's degree or higher, contributing to the area's affluence.
- 4.6% poverty rate reflects economic stability.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 5-Year Data Profiles.
Crime & Safety: What the Numbers Say
Crime data for New York state shows some concerning trends. The violent crime rate is 454.9 per 100,000, significantly higher than the national average of 325.3. Property crime is also above the national rate, with 1,816.5 per 100,000 compared to the national average of 1,546.9. Notably, the homicide rate has decreased by 34.5% since 2022, now at 2.7 per 100,000.
- Violent crime: 454.9 per 100,000 vs. national 325.3
- Property crime: 1,816.5 per 100,000 vs. national 1,546.9
- Notable trend: Homicide rate down 34.5% since 2022
Source: FBI Crime Data Explorer (state-level summarized data for New York).
Schools & Higher Ed
East Setauket has access to several educational institutions nearby, enhancing educational opportunities for residents.
- Total postsecondary institutions: 5
- Institutions with College Scorecard data: 5
- Notable nearby schools include Stony Brook University and Suffolk County Community College.
Source: ArcGIS Postsecondary School Locations, NCES, College Scorecard.
Weather & Getting Outside
While climate data is unavailable, East Setauket offers several outdoor parks worth exploring, perfect for enjoying nature.
- Sunken Meadow State Park - 4.6 stars from 9,014 reviews
- Cedar Beach Town Nature Preserve - 4.7 stars from 2,118 reviews
- Avalon Nature Preserve - 4.8 stars from 1,527 reviews
- Blydenburgh County Park - 4.6 stars from 1,347 reviews
Source: Google Places API.